Highlights
-
The Keys moved from elevated supply toward buyer-leaning balance.
-
The average price increased faster than the median, suggesting a possible shift in expensive closings.
-
Fewer available homes narrowed buyer choice.
-
More completed sales coincided with a shorter marketing period.
-
Buyers retained more leverage than the countywide supply reading suggests.
Market Conditions
Sarasota Keys tightened in October 2026 as completed sales rose while available inventory declined. The market moved away from last year’s elevated supply, although 5.9 months still supports balanced-to-buyer-leaning conditions rather than a broad shortage.
The figures combine single-family homes, condos, townhomes, and villas. Comparisons are year over year, between October 2026 and October 2025.
The Keys carried more supply than Sarasota County’s 4.2 months. Its 70-day median marketing period also exceeded the county’s 46 days, giving buyers a less hurried setting than the countywide figures imply.
Pricing Trends
The median, the midpoint of completed sales, increased 16.5%, from $1,030,000 to $1,200,000. The average, which is more sensitive to expensive closings, increased 38.6%, from $1,840,000 to $2,550,000.
The larger increase in the average may reflect a more expensive mix of upper-end closings. Both measures rose, but the data does not isolate appreciation in comparable waterfront or island homes.
Inventory Trends
Available inventory declined 19.9%, from 637 to 510 listings. Months of supply fell from 11.1 to 5.9, measuring available choice relative to the sales pace.
Buyers had 127 fewer listings to consider. Supply fell below October 2019’s 8.3 months but remained well above October 2021’s 1.6 months, showing a tighter market with continued alternatives.
Market Pace
Closed sales, which measure completed transactions, increased 20.6%, from 63 to 76. Median days on market fell from 99 to 70 days.
The 20.6% increase in closings contrasted with the county’s 1.7% decline. The 29-day improvement in marketing time reinforces the stronger completed activity, although sales still took longer than countywide.
What This Means for Buyers
Buyers have fewer island options but retain room to compare and negotiate. Judge asking prices against similar properties and recent closings, especially where expensive sales can move the average. Be ready to respond when a well-priced home fits specific needs.
What This Means for Sellers
Sellers benefit from fewer competing listings and more completed activity. Nearly six months of supply still rewards careful preparation and realistic pricing. Base timing on island comparables rather than the faster countywide median.